• CCA Student Sign In

Filthy Rich Writer

The #1 All-in-One Online Copywriting Program

The #1 All-in-One Online Copywriting Training Program

  • What Is Copywriting?
    • What Is Copywriting?
    • Why Copywriting is the BEST Career for Writers
  • Blog
    • Most Popular
    • Mindset & Professional Development
    • Portfolio
    • Business Development
    • Book Recommendations
    • Pitching
    • Copywriting Tips
    • Terms to Know
  • Podcast
    • Build Your Copywriting Business Podcast
    • Latest Episodes
    • Student Stories
  • Copywriting Training
    • Learn About the Comprehensive Copywriting Academy
    • CCA Next Level
  • CCA Reviews
    • CCA Reviews
    • Videos: CCA Student Stories
    • Videos: CCA Student Reviews
    • CCA Student Wins
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • About Nicki Krawczyk
    • Press
  • Copywriting Tools

Episode 126: Good vs. Bad Copywriting: How Do You Tell the Difference?

By Nicki Krawczyk

The question of “What makes copy good or bad?” is often spun by our students into “Am I a good copywriter?” It’s a simple question with a not-always-so-simple answer.

In this episode, Nicki and Kate dive into unraveling the answer, and how asking yourself if something is good copy or bad copy, will make you a better copywriter.

TUNE IN: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Stitcher

Looking for closed captioning or a transcript? Watch the episode on YouTube!


A Sneak Peek at the Episode

[2:10] The question of “What makes copy good or bad?” is often spun by our students into “Am I a good copywriter?” It’s a simple question with a not always so simple answer.

[4:20] When looking at an ad, even if you are not the target audience, put yourself is their shoes. Does it make sense to you? Does it connect with you as the customer? Using the words good or bad is too black and white.

[7:30] It’s important to take a moment and analyze what you are seeing, because if you learn to analyze the work of others you will become able to analyze yours much more effectively.

[10:45] You might be surprised at some of the places you find effective copy and what makes it so effective. It might be elements beyond copy that are getting you to take action, copy doesn’t live in a vacuum.

[18:40] If you are out there evaluating copy and you’re going “this is good, this hits the points, oh, this is not good, this is missing the points” you are ahead of the game. The next step to build your skills is to take the time to and work on a rewrite, what would you say instead.

[21:30] The question we often hear from students is “how do I know if I’m a good copywriter, how can I be a good copywriter?” This concern or resistance is a natural part of the process of learning a new skill.

[23:30] If you are in a project and feeling lost, go back to the fundamentals. As long as you are delivering those fundamental elements of copy, that make that copy good, then you are a good writer of copy.

[25:00] The writing of the copy is only one portion of what we do as copywriters. We strategize with and guide our clients. The copywriter is partner with the client.


Filthy Rich Writer mug sits on desk while Nicki's hand writes in notebook.

“A good copywriter is someone who writes good copy and as such, a good copywriter writes good copy that does talk to the benefit, speaks to the target audience, that does have a call to action.” – Nicki

“It might not be bad copy, it might have just gotten to the wrong person.” – Kate


Get an *Exclusive* Bonus Recording!

Tell us what you love about the podcast and what you hope to hear next! When you do, you can get access to an exclusive bonus recording featuring five wildly successful entrepreneurs who share what they do (and don’t!) look for when hiring copywriters. You do not want to miss it! 

Get all the details on how to get your recording here »


About the Build Your Business Podcast

Nicki, one of the hosts of the Build Your Copywriting Business podcast, sits at a black table with six chairs, four white, two black, as she records a podcast episode with a microphone, laptop, and doughnut in front of her.

Ready to turn your love of writing into a successful copywriting career?

Join professional copywriters Nicki Krawczyk and Kate Sitarz to get the tips, tools, and training to help you become a copywriter and build a thriving business of your own. Nicki and Kate have 20+ and 10+ years of experience, respectively, writing copy for multi-billion-dollar companies, solopreneurs, and every size business in between.

Whether you want to land an on-staff job, freelance full-time and work from wherever you want, or make extra money with a side hustle, the best place to start learning is right here.


See Previous Episode

Ep. 125: How to Calm Your Nerves Before Copywriting Client Calls

Last Updated on November 18, 2024

Filed Under: Podcast

Interested in Copywriting? Get our Free Video Training!

Plus, get on the list for updates, freebies, and more :) 



About Nicki Krawczyk

Nicki is a copywriter, copy coach and the founder of Filthy Rich Writer. She's been writing copy for more than 20 years.

Click here to subscribe

Break Into Copywriting

Sign up to get our FREE video training, special resources, and more!



Click here to subscribe

Comprehensive Copywriting Academy

Join the copywriting training program that's helping people just like you build successful copywriting careers!

Learn more
Comprehensive Copywriting Academy from Filthy Rich Writer

Portfolio Tips

  • Nicki Krawczyk, founder of Filthy Rich Writer and the Build Your Copywriting Business podcast
    Ep. 43: 4 Biggest Copywriter Portfolio Mistakes
  • Home office with desktop computer, tablet, and a mobile
    3 Copywriter Portfolio Examples That Wow Clients
  • Nicki Krawczyk, founder of Filthy Rich Writer and the Build Your Copywriting Business podcast
    Ep. 22: Why Every Copywriter MUST Have an Online Portfolio

Top Resources

  • What is Copywriting?
  • How Much Do Copywriters Actually Make?
  • Is Copywriting Hard to Get Into?
  • Why Copywriting Certificates Are B-S
  • How Soon Can You Make Money as a Copywriter?
  • What Does a Copywriter Actually Do?
  • Copywriting vs. Copyediting: What's the Difference?
  • Avoid the Copywriting Niche Trap
  • Upwork is NOT the Path to Copywriting Success
  • Getting Started in the Comprehensive Copywriting Academy

Recent Articles

  • Nicki and Kate sit at a table with podcast recording microphones, notebooks, and Filthy Rich Writer mugs, with the words "Build Your Copywriting Business" above them.
    Episode 227: How Do I Write an About Page? [Copywriting Tips]
  • Nicki and Kate sit at a table with podcast recording microphones, notebooks, and Filthy Rich Writer mugs, with the words "Build Your Copywriting Business" above them.
    Episode 225: What Jobs Can I Do As a Copywriter?
  • Nicki and Kate sit at a table with podcast recording microphones, notebooks, and Filthy Rich Writer mugs, with the words "Build Your Copywriting Business" above them.
    Episode 223: If Not Now, When? A Deep Dive Into Decision Making
  • Nicki and Kate sit at a table with podcast recording microphones, notebooks, and Filthy Rich Writer mugs, with the words "Build Your Copywriting Business" above them.
    Episode 221: “I Don’t Want To!” Tactics for Completing Un-Fun Tasks
  • Nicki and Kate sit at a table with podcast recording microphones, notebooks, and Filthy Rich Writer mugs, with the words "Build Your Copywriting Business" above them.
    Episode 220: How to Have Uncomfortable Client and Work Conversations
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn

Copyright © 2025 Filthy Rich Writer | Contact Us | FAQs |About Us | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy| Business Affiliates

Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}